![]() |
| Statement posted Tuesday to social media |
Writer, Haunt Hunters App
SPRINGFIELD, Mo. – After years of legal battles and public debate, Hotel of Terror announced Tuesday it will close permanently following the upcoming haunted house season.
Local news reports indicated the settlement between Hotel of Terror Owners Sterling and Melissa Mathis was $2 million with a provision that the attraction remain open for one more season.
In a statement posted to social media on Tuesday, the family behind the long-running attraction confirmed they have reached a settlement with the city, ending an eminent domain dispute that has hung over the property for years.
The payment from the city is not enough to rebuild the haunt, according to the statement, but the family no longer wants the stress of the prolonged battle.
“This has been an emotional and exhausting experience,” and the stress has greatly affected my family, especially my wife's health," according to the statement. "With this settlement, it is impossible to rebuild.”
Hotel of Terror, a fixture of the region’s fall season for nearly 50 years, became the center of controversy when the city announced plans that would require acquisition of the property through eminent domain.
City officials argued the land was needed for redevelopment, while the owners maintained that the compensation offered did not reflect the value of the business or the years invested in building the attraction.
Rather than accepting the initial offer, the family fought the action and ultimately succeeded in pushing the issue to a public referendum, a move that drew significant attention and community support.
Fans of the haunted house rallied behind the owners, viewing the fight as a stand against government overreach and a defense of a locally owned business with deep roots in the area.
Despite that support, the dispute dragged on, leaving the future of the attraction uncertain from one season to the next. In their statement, the owners said the prolonged legal fight and lack of resolution made continuing no longer viable.
The upcoming season will now serve as the Hotel of Terror’s final run. The family said they plan to open one last time to give longtime patrons a chance to return and say goodbye.
“We are grateful to everyone in the community who has supported us and stood by us through the years,” the statement said.
Fans of Hotel of Terror posted responded to the settlement with sadness, but, said they understood why the owners, eventually, agreed to the settlement.
“What a shame. I’m sorry to hear this and I don’t blame you at all,” one person wrote. “That kind of stress can ruin a family. We will definitely be supporting you this season. Prime example of how nothing is really yours. The government can, and will, take your house or land anytime they want to. Too many people don’t understand that.”
Another person said the news was “extremely tragic.”
“I'm so sorry for this loss, to you and your family, especially, but also to the whole community,” according to the post. “The building, itself, is such a big part of Springfield history. I'm so sad (and angry) that it's so easy for them to rob you, financially, and also mentally. None of us in the community can be as hurt as you guys are, of course. But we are hurt. This is extremely tragic that this building means nothing to so many.”
Dungeons of Doom in Springfield, also owned by the Mathis Family, will remain open.








